Favorite and Least Favorite Books of the Year Part 2

Last week, I shared my favorite and least favorite books from the first half of the year (January-May). This week, I'm sharing my favorite and least favorite books from the second half (June-October). This was so much harder, probably because the books are fresher in my mind and the details haven't quite faded to a hazy overall impression yet. I ruthlessly culled, though, and chose just one for each category!


June




Favorite: The Fourth Consort, by Edward Ashton

Rating: 4.5 stars

Release Year: 2025

I'm not a huge sci-fi fan, but I loved this book! I can't wait for Ashton's next book, which is set to come out early next year.


Least Favorite: Under the Same Stars, by Libba Bray

Rating: 3.5 stars

Release Year: 2025

I really had to force myself through Jenny's chapters.


July




Favorite: Miracle Creek, by Angie Kim

Rating: 4 stars

Release Year: 2019

I was not okay after reading this book.


Least Favorite: Haben: The Deafblind Woman Who Conquered Harvard Law, by Haben Girma

Rating: 4 stars

Release Year: 2019

Looking back, my star rating was too high. I think I ranked it on merit, but on craft it definitely takes the prize for least favorite. The writing style felt very dumbed down, especially considering she's a lawyer, and I expected that more of the book would take place at Harvard (since it's in the subtitle). However, I did enjoy learning about the technologies and strategies she uses as a person who is deafblind.


August




Favorite: Aftertaste, by Daria Lavelle

Rating: 5 stars

Release Year: 2025

Hands down, no contest. This was one of my favorite books of the entire year so far.


Least Favorite: The Hemlock Queen, by Hannah F. Whitten

Rating: 3 stars

Release Year: 2024

I really liked the first book, but this one just left me feeling icky for some reason. I don't even have the desire to read the third one.


September




Favorite: The Hiding Place, by Corrie ten Boom

Rating: 5 stars

Release Year: 1971

This was almost a tie between The Hiding Place and Catching Fire, but I know The Hiding Place will have a much deeper, lasting impact on me than Catching Fire will.


Least Favorite: Brideshead Revisited, by Evelyn Waugh (Audiobook)

Rating: 2 stars

Release Year: 1945

Possibly my least favorite read of the year so far. My sister wasn't kidding; it was horrible.


October




Favorite: The Names, by Florence Knapp

Rating: 5 stars

Release Year: 2025 

Honorable mention goes to Starling House, but The Names was just so good.


Least Favorite: Hangsaman, by Shirley Jackson

Rating: 2.5 stars 

Release Year: 1951

The Heartbreak Hotel by Ellen O'Clover deserves a mention here, but Hangsaman was honestly dreadful. It made no sense. (I used the Penguin Classics paperback cover here because the edition I read was part of a collection of Shirley Jackson's novels.)


There's a surprising number of new releases on this list! Did I mention any of your favorites (or least favorites)? Next week, I'll be joining up with Top Ten Tuesday for a Thanksgiving Freebie post!


Comments